Located on the vibrant Millburn Avenue, Bagel Pantry Short Hills has been a cornerstone of the community. We believe that exceptional bagels start with simple ingredients, time-honored techniques, and an unwavering commitment to freshness.
Every bagel is hand-rolled in small batches, boiled to perfection, and baked until golden. Our house-made cream cheese and premium toppings elevate the classic bagel into an experience you won't forget.
Every bagel shaped with care
Only the finest ingredients
From classic everything to our famous lox platters, every item is crafted with the same dedication to quality.
House-smoked lox, our signature whipped cream cheese, capers, red onion, and tomato on a fresh everything bagel.
Order Now
Two eggs any style, crispy bacon or sausage, hash browns, and your choice of fresh bagel with cream cheese.
Order Now
Start your morning right with a fresh bagel of your choice and a large premium coffee. The perfect pairing.
Order Now
We're located in the heart of Short Hills on Millburn Avenue. Stop by for fresh bagels, great coffee, and friendly service.
518 Millburn Avenue
Short Hills, NJ 07078
(197) 393-9174
bagelpantryshorthills@gmail.com
